Booze & Boarders

Note that this work is incomplete.The timelines we write are meant to be fluid and changing. That is one of the reasons they are described as abridged. Not only do we not include all the details in them, but there is always more to find, and always more to write. Overtime more sources are found, more stories are heard, and more tips are followed until a full article is ready to be written.

When we last left Mr. Charles Kobella, he was just embarking in the hotel business and starting on his true path to notoriety…

Apr 1905, Kobella arrested for drunk and disorderly, had been out with friends in the country and came back into town drunk, paid his $5 fine ($159.05 today)

June 1905 Wisconsin Census lists, Charles Kobella 44, Gusta 39, Martha 17, John 12, Frank 10, 4 male boarders, and 86 year old female servant, Mary Yarjeski.

July 1905 Kobella and Volenty Witczek REFUSED by the committee for a liquor license

Aug 1905, license refused again, tried to put it in an employee’s name, N. Wolosik, “an irresponsible young man in Kobela’s employ.” The newspaper called it “an institution that has caused the police department and the fathers and mothers of the Fourth ward much anxiety and trouble for some time.” The police chief reported that Kobella laughed in his face when they tried to regulate the “hotel of questionable character.” The Polski Hotel had been open just two years at this point!

Sept 1905 Kobella arrested for selling liquor without a license and “fined $50 and costs, a total of $53.50, or the price of 10,700 glasses of beer.” $53.50 would be $1,663.16 or 10,700 15 cent beers today

Oct 1905 License denied for the third time in the year!!  The newspaper called the hotel “an institution of unsavory reputation.”

Nov 1905  License applied for in Mike Strelavag’s name, refused again. AGAIN!

In Dec 1905  Frank Kluck was successful in getting a license for the Kobella Hotel, but wanted out by February of the following year. Kluck quit and took his license, as well as any profits, also leaving Kobella with a hefty bank note according to reports. “Saloon licenses are not transferable either as to location or proprietorship.” Which meant Kobella couldn’t legally operate and Kluck couldn’t move his license to another building.

Feb 1907, A young woman known as “Black Rose” attempts suicide the street by drinking carbolic acid but survives! She had worked at the Kobella hotel until August of 1906, but “was taken in hand by Chief Leahy and advised to leave the city.” She went to Fond du Lac but had returned and attempted suicide on the street in front of Worzella’s dry goods store. She was “without funds and was despondent and had been advised a certain party to end it all with carbolic acid and had been furnished with money to buy it with.” Horribly, carbolic acid was a common way to commit suicide at the time, and easily available. Note this is the first actual account of possible prostitution at the Polski Hotel noted in the newspapers as far as we know.

July 1907 Kobella arrested for assault and battery of Mary Witczek at the hotel property. “Alleges that the defendant severely beat and bruised her…After the alleged assault, the woman had a fit at engine house No. 1 and was placed in the calaboose.” Very likely the wife of Volenty or Valentine Witczek, mentioned before as one the names for the first known license that was refused. They lived on the south side of town on Patch Street. Was Mary “working” at Kobella’s?

Nov 1907, The state picked up the Witczek case but DISMISSED it in the end. Kobella paid a fine of $37.95.

Dec 1907 Kobella arrested AGAIN for an assault that took place at his saloon at 2am. AB Klestinski, brought warrant, but eventually settled out of court in January.  This is the fourth assault he is involved with for those of you keeping track.

1908 City Directory, Kobella, T.C. & Co, hotel and saloon, 245 N. Second Street, Kobella T. Charles; Kobella, Martha, domestic, 245 N. Second Street

March 1908 Kobella denied license again after the testimony of Judge Murat and Police chief Leahy. That same month his application for citizenship was denied while three others were immediately approved. “Judge JA Murat, Sheriff Frank Guyant, and Chief of police John Lehy were called as witnesses for the government…” Kobella didn’t even wait in court to find out if his application was approved. He left before they even finished the proceedings.

April 1908, A false engagement of Martha Kobella and Walter Bernklau was announced in the SPDJ, but was publicly denied the next day by Martha.

May 1909, Kobella bought the old Curran house “bus” and had it “repainted and relettered, ‘Hotel Polski.’”

July 1909, Kobella denied again! Fifty-one applicants and two brewers’ license. The committee recommended licensing them all except for “Kobella’s Hotel Polski.”

Oct 1909, Surprise! Liquor license denied for the property again. Peter Broski applied this round.

Oct 1909 Martha Kobella and well-known local Spanish war hero, Joe Mattice are married, ironically, by Judge Murat at the Hotel Denver, where they are both employed and living. They soon move to Milwaukee where Joe takes a job “in a factory at Milwaukee’s big suburb.” You can read a bit about the Hotel Denver building, also known as Hotel Sellers as well as a few other names, here.

Watch for Part 3 coming soon!

Read Part 1 here